The fourth and final product within the camomile range for me to try. Well, I loved the others so I’m gonna love this one too, right? …Right? WRONG.
The Body Shop Camomile Gentle Eye Makeup Remover surprised me. I’d go as far as saying it didn’t even feel like it was genuinely part of the same range.
With the rest of the range, I found that the products were extremely gentle on my sensitive skin – they didn’t tug, they left no redness and my skin would be left feeling super soft. Whilst this water doesn’t generally leave any redness, I do find it harder to work with. The cotton pad needs to be pretty well soaked to avoid excessive tugging and discomfort (who wants sore eyes after removing their makeup?!) but you’ve also got to be careful not to go too crazy otherwise it drips into your eyes and gets disastrous. Kinda burns.. I speak from experience.
I don’t use waterproof eye makeup, but have found I need to hold a soaked cotton pad over the eye for a bit before attempting to wipe anything away. Even so, this product really struggles – especially with eyeliner.
I have tried using this all over the face too, after the oil/butter to complete removal as I do with the waterproof remover. I’d rather just wash my face.
On top of all that, there’s a peculiar scent I’m not familiar with. None of the other camomile products have this scent.
All in all, I certainly wouldn’t recommend this product. I’ll be repurchasing the Waterproof Eye & Lip Makeup Remover to relieve my eyeballs and I’ll be sticking to more oil based products for makeup removal from here on out!
The Body Shop Camomile Gentle Eye Makeup Remover get a 1/5 from me.
I can’t even say the packaging is a point booster as it’s really plain and I’m not a fan of opaque bottles. I like to be able to see how much product I have left. 250ml seems like a decent size, but I have to use more than I would of any other product each time so I don’t really save. At £7.50 I’d personally pay the extra £2.50 for the waterproof remover, but you can definitely get a more efficient micellar water for less money.
1 point for successful removal of mascara from some of my lashes on single-coat mascara days.
Have you tried The Body Shop Camomile Gentle Eye Makeup Remover?
And my updated thoughts on the range
Find me elsewhere: